Vipul Singh
Historians, in general, stress the need for in-depth examination of specific regions and localities to write historical narratives. They study a wide range of topics related to human societies, including political history, social history, economic history, cultural history, and intellectual history. Among the practitioners of history, there is often an emphasis on narrow specialisation. Scholars are encouraged to become experts in particular periods, regions, or themes, which can limit their exploration of broader, cross-cutting themes. They may focus on specific aspects of human experience such as wars, revolutions, social movements, cultural developments, economic trends, and political systems in a micro region or at macro level. The pressure to maintain deep expertise in a specific area often deter historians from venturing into interdisciplinary or cross-cultural studies. Although over the recent years, historians are increasingly recognising the importance of embracing interdisciplinary approaches and many a historians are engaging with diverse perspectives across the geographies. They acknowledge that a more holistic understanding of history requires attention to both local intricacies and global interconnections. Interestingly, nature rarely draws much attention in all these histories. Despite nature’s integral role in human existence, it has received limited attention, despite its significance throughout history.
History as a discipline has evolved very fast and in diverse ways. Critical approaches have allowed historians to question traditional assumptions and interpretations. But unfortunately, these new interpretations and ideas have failed to touch upon environmental issues. One of the reasons could be the absence of direct evidence coming from the primary sources, such as archives and chronicles. Environmental historians do something new and try to explore human-nature relationships with the help of bio-archives along with the existing conventional sources. They are increasingly cognisant of the significance of studying topics that transcend geographical and cultural boundaries. They recognize that environmental issues often have global implications and require cross-cultural perspectives for comprehensive understanding. By transcending narrow disciplinary boundaries and adopting a more inclusive approach, historians have been able to enrich their scholarship. They have been able to contribute to a more comprehensive understanding of human history and its relationship with the environment.
The examination of the relationship between humans and the natural world began to receive significant scholarly attention starting in the 1970s, coining the term “environmental history” to define this emerging field of study.
What does Environmental history encompass?
Environmental history (EH) is basically the exploration of the dynamic interaction between human societies and the natural environment throughout history. It tries to understand the ways in which people have relied on, altered, and been influenced by the natural world, considering various dimensions such as political, economic, cultural, and social factors. To that end EH does not compartmentalize traditional historical subjects like politics, society, economy, or culture but rather integrates them into its analysis, examining their implications for the environment and vice versa.
Environmental historians see how human actions, policies, and beliefs have influenced and been influenced by the natural world over time. They explore topics such as land use, resource management, ecological changes, environmental degradation, conservation efforts, and the evolution of environmental ideas and movements. They pay particular attention to processes of environmental change, including deforestation, urbanization, industrialization, pollution, climate change, extinction, and the impact of human activities on ecosystems and biodiversity. They explore how these changes have shaped human societies and cultures and influenced historical developments.
The main areas of inquiry within environmental history include the material aspects of human interaction with nature, such as water resources, forests, soil, animals, minerals, and disease. Additionally, EH investigates the transformation of nature through political and policy-related lenses, examining human efforts to regulate the relationship between society and the environment. It also delves into the cultural encounter with nature, analysing artistic expressions, myths, beliefs, and perceptions related to the natural world throughout history.
Why Environmental History is NOT Environmental Determinism?
Many think that since environmental history also examines nature’s role in human history it is nothing but environmental determinism. This is a misconception. EH is not deterministic. It does acknowledge that environmental factors influence human societies, but humans also possess the capacity to adapt, innovate, and transform their environments in response to changing circumstances. Individuals and societies make conscious decisions and take deliberate actions that can have profound impacts on their environment, sometimes mitigating or even reversing environmental challenges. An environmental historian recognises that cultural beliefs, social norms, political institutions, and economic systems play crucial roles in shaping human-environment relationships. These factors influence how societies perceive, interact with, and utilize their natural surroundings. Cultural values, religious beliefs, and societal priorities often determine how resources are managed, landscapes are shaped, and environmental policies are formulated. Historical outcomes are shaped by a multitude of interconnected factors, including political decisions, economic conditions, cultural dynamics, and environmental constraints. So, we may say that environmental factors although may influence historical trajectories, they do not determine outcomes in a deterministic sense.
The primary task of environmental history is to unravel the intricate connections between humans and nature over time, exploring how human actions have shaped ecosystems and how environmental changes have, in turn, impacted human societies. This discipline encompasses both human impacts on the environment and nature’s influence on human affairs, highlighting the reciprocal nature of these relationships. From changes in land use to alterations in natural cycles, environmental historians evaluate the multifaceted interactions between human and non-human entities, acknowledging the complex interplay that shapes historical trajectories.
What is Global Environmental History?
Global environmental history (GEH) builds upon the principles of EH but adopts a broader perspective by examining phenomena at a global scale. It offers insights into complex global processes and connections, such as the destruction of tropical forests linked to economic models and international trade networks. While global environmental history shares common themes and methodologies with world environmental history, it emphasises a wider scope and often incorporates analytical frameworks like environmental determinism, cultural ecology, political ecology, colonialism, imperialism, and concepts such as anthropocene, capitalocene and plantationocene.
In nutshell, while environmental history explores human-environment relationships over time, global environmental history expands this inquiry to encompass global phenomena and interconnections, shedding light on the complex dynamics shaping our world.
[Total: 1200 words]
10 minutes read
Speaking History 
Leave a comment